Main










Applications


Identities







History


FAQ


Algorithms



                                             

Binomial Coefficient Identities and Proofs Listed by Category

On this page, B.C. is short for binomial coefficient

All references to page and problem numbers in Concrete Mathematics refer to the second printing, ©1989


Navigating this list


Category List

Sums

Products

Sums of Products

Products of Sums

Factorization Identities

Identities by Name


Identities Involving Famous Numbers



                                                            Category 1:  Sums

1.0: B.C. = B.C.   

1.3: (non-B.C.s) = B.C.

1.1:  B.C.s = B.C. and B.C.s = B.C.s 

1.4: B.C.s = (non-B.C.s)

1.2: B.C.s = non-B.C.

1.5: B.C.s = mixed product

 
                                                            Category 2:  Products

2.1:  B.C.s = B.C. And B.C.s =  B.C.s

2.4: mixed product = B.C.

2.2: B.C.s = non-B.C.

2.5: mixed product = non-B.C.

2.3: (non-B.C.s) = B.C.



                                                            Category 3:  Sums of Products

3.1: ( B.C.s) = B.C. and ( B.C.s) = B.C.s
and
( B.C.s) = (mixed products)

3.6: (alt. product) = alt. product

3.2: ( B.C.s) = non-B.C.

3.6.1: (alt. product) = non-B.C.

3.3: ( non-B.C.s) = B.C.

3.7: (mixed product) = mixed product and
(mixed product) = (mixed product)

3.4: (alternating product) = B.C. or B.C.

3.8: (mixed product) = alt. product

3.5: (mixed product) = B.C., B.C. or B.C.

3.9: (mixed product) = non-B.C.


                                                            Category 4:  Products of Sums

4.1: ( B.C.s) = B.C.

4.3: ( non-B.C.s) = B.C.

4.2: ( B.C.s) = non-B.C.



                                                            Category 5:  Identities (mod n) and factors

5.1: Identities mod p or powers of  p for p prime

5.3: Identities involving factorization

5.2: Identities mod n for n not necessarily a prime power



 
   

Identities Involving Famous Numbers


Identities that are (almost) always zero


Euler Numbers


Explanation of Euler Numbers



Fibonacci Numbers

Explanation of Fibonacci Numbers


Stirling Numbers of the 1st Kind

Explanation of Stirling Numbers of the 1st Kind


Stirling Numbers of the 2nd Kind

Explanation of Stirling Numbers of the 2nd Kind



Gaussian Coefficients




Explanation of the Catalan Numbers and Narayana Numbers



Catalan and Narayana Numbers



Explanation of the Delannoy Numbers


Delannoy Numbers


Powers of 2


Central Binomial Coefficients

  
  




Main










Applications


Identities







History


FAQ


Algorithms



                                                        Category 1: Identities involving sums


1.0: B.C. = B.C.

Catalog #: 1000001

                             
Known as: The Symmetry Rule, Pascal’s 4th Identity
Proof
One of the Top Ten Identities

Return to top





Main










Applications


Identities







History


FAQ


Algorithms



1.1:  B.C.s = B.C. and B.C.s = B.C.s

Catalog #: 1100001

                         
Known as:  The Basic Additive Identity, Pascal’s 1st Identity
Proof
One of the Top Ten Identities

Catalog #: 1100002

                         
Known as: Upper Summation and Parallel Summation (respectively), The Christmas Stocking Theorem, Pascal’s 2nd  Identity
Sometimes incorrectly called The Hockey Stick Theorem (see Cat. # 3400001)
Proof
One of the Top Ten Identities

Catalog #: 1100003

                     
Known as: Pascal’s 3rd Identity
Hint: Multiple uses of the Christmas Stocking Theorem

Catalog #: 1100004

                         
Known as: Sums of Rows Doubling,  1st part, Pascal’s 5th Identity
Proof

Catalog #: 1100005

               
Known as: Partial Row Sum Rule, Pascal’s 6th Identity

Catalog #: 1100006

                 
Known as:  Pascal’s 11th Identity

Catalog #: 1100007


                 
 The second difference equation of the row sequence is zero only at these values (and their mirror images on the same row) among all rows of Pascal’s Triangle
Proof

Return to top


 




Main










Applications


Identities







History


FAQ


Algorithms



1.2: B.C.s = non-B.C.

Catalog #: 1200001

                 
Known as: Row Sum Identity, Pascal’s 5th Identity
Hint:  The difference triangle for the sequence 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, 32, ...

Catalog #: 1200002

               
Proof by picture
Generalized in Cat. # 3600002

Catalog #: 1200003
, where f0 = 0, f1 = 1 and fn = fn-1 + fn-2, the Fibonacci numbers  
                 
Known as: The Binomial to Fibonacci Identity
Proof

Catalog #: 1200004
= # of non-negative integer 3×3 matrices where all row and column sums = n            
               
from Enumerative Combinatorics, Chapter 2, problem 6b

Catalog #: 1200005
where  is the ceiling of x, smallest integer n >= x
               
from Concrete Mathematics, page 228

Catalog #: 1200006
where rmax(n) for positive integers n is the maximum number of regions created in a circle by connecting n points on the circumference with straight lines
              
from The Colossal Book of Mathematics, page 561 by Martin Gardner; answered credited to Leo Moser
Note: first five entries are 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, but rmax(6) = 6 + 15 + 10 = 31 and rmax(7) = 57
As a polynomial, the function can be written as (n4 - 6n3 + 23n2 - 18n + 24)/24

Catalog #: 1200007


from Table of integrals, series, and products by Gradshteyn and Ryzhik

Catalog #: 1200008


from Table of integrals, series, and products by Gradshteyn and Ryzhik

Catalog #: 1200009


from Table of integrals, series, and products by Gradshteyn and Ryzhik

Catalog #: 1200010

 

from Table of integrals, series, and products by Gradshteyn and Ryzhik

Catalog #: 1200011

 

from Table of integrals, series, and products by Gradshteyn and Ryzhik

Catalog #: 1200012
 


from Table of integrals, series, and products by Gradshteyn and Ryzhik

Catalog #: 1200013
 


from Table of integrals, series, and products by Gradshteyn and Ryzhik

Catalog #: 1200014

where F is a set of subsets of the set {1, 2, ..., n} such that no element of F is a subset of another element of F (this type of set sometimes called an antichain)

known as Sperner's Theorem
from Proof Techniques in the Theory of Finite Sets by Greene and Kleitman
published in MAA Studies In Mathematics, Vol. 17, edited by Rota
Hint:  If we take all subsets of some fixed equal size, none of them can be subsets of each other.

Catalog #: 1200015
For all positive integers m and k, there is a unique k-binomial representation of m

Hint: find the largest value in row k that is less than m, subtract that value from m, repeat the process on the remainder in row k-1, etc.

Catalog #: 1200016



known as Kruskal-Katona Theorem
uses the k-binomial representation from the identity above

Catalog #: 1200017
where fn is the nth Fibonacci number, starting with f0 = 0, f1 = 1, etc.

from Proofs that Really Count by Benjamin and Quinn, page 78

Catalog #: 1200018
where fn is the nth Fibonacci number, starting with f0 = 0, f1 = 1, etc.

from Proofs that Really Count by Benjamin and Quinn, page 78
Hint:  #1200017 and #1200018 can be proven from #1200003 and the symmetry rule, #1000001


Return to top





Main










Applications


Identities







History


FAQ


Algorithms



1.3: (non-B.C.s) = B.C.

Catalog #: 1300001

Known as: The relationship between the triangular numbers Tn and the 2nd column of Pascal’s Triangle.

Catalog #: 1300002
 
Picture Proof                         


Catalog #: 1300003

                      
Known as: sum of odd cubes
Picture Proof 

Catalog #: 1300004


(Note: Last subscript is ak -1.)


communicated by Ron Ozer


Return to top





Main










Applications


Identities







History


FAQ


Algorithms



1.4: B.C.s = (non-B.C.s)

Catalog #: 1400001

                     
Two ways to write the square numbers (see Cat. #: 1200002)

Return to top





Main










Applications


Identities







History


FAQ


Algorithms



1.5: B.C.s = mixed product

Catalog #: 1500001

                     
  Known as: Pascal’s 9th Identity

Catalog #: 1500002

                     
  Known as: Pascal’s 10th Identity

Return to top


 




Main










Applications


Identities







History


FAQ


Algorithms



                                                Category 2: Identities involving products and quotients



2.1:  B.C.s = B.C. And B.C.s =  B.C.s

Catalog #: 2100001

                         
Known as: trinomial revision
Hint: write out the fractions
From Concrete Mathematics, page 174
Note:  In his book Combinatorial Identities, Riordan writes that trinomial revision has 48 alternative forms.
One of the Top Ten Identities

Catalog #: 2100002

             
Known as:  The Star of David rule or The Hexagon Property
Hint: write out the fractions
From Concrete Mathematics, page 155
Compare to Cat. #: 5300001, the g.c.d version of the Star of David rule

Catalog #: 2100003

Hint: write out the fractions
communicated by Pieter H. Van Der Kamp

Catalog #: 2100004

Hint: Cat. #2100003 and Cat. #2300003, distinguish between odd and even cases
communicated by Pieter H. Van Der Kamp


Return to top





Main










Applications


Identities







History


FAQ


Algorithms



2.2: B.C.s = non-B.C.

Catalog #: 2200001

 , where all si are positive integers
                
Formula for binomial to multinomial coefficients
Example:  

Catalog #: 2200002

                          
picture proof  
communicated by Rick West


Catalog #: 2200003


Catalog #: 2200004

communicated by Sebastián Martín Ruiz
Hint:  Look at the middle product for the square matrix of ordered pairs Ai,j = (i, j)

Return to top





Main










Applications


Identities







History


FAQ


Algorithms



2.3: (non-B.C.s) = B.C.

Catalog #: 2300001

  Known as: the factorial fractional formula
One of the Top Ten Identities

Catalog #: 2300002
 , where nk = n(n-1)…(n-k+1) written also as (n)k in Stanley
  Known as falling factorial representation, simplest when k <= ½n

Catalog #: 2300003
                     
Pascal’s Last Identity (from Part 2 of the Treatise)
Hint: write out the fractions

Return to top





Main